Redford's Rookie is a Natural

You've got a gift Roy... but it's not enough - you've got to develop yourself. If you rely too much on your own gift... then... you'll fail - Ed Hobbs

Robert Redford in The Natural (1984)

As a young boy Roy Hobbs (Robert Redford) had a god given talent for baseball and along with the bat he hand crafted he heads off in the hope of making it to the big time. But his dream is shattered when he meets a mysterious woman whilst travelling by train. 16 years later and Roy suddenly reappears making it to the big time and the New York Knights where he not only has to overcome the prejudices of coach Pop Fisher (Wilford Brimley) who thinks he's too old, but also physical pain to help the Knights win the pennant.

As a baseball movie Robert Redford's "The Natural" has those big hitting batter moments, the choreographed crowd pleasers designed to lift the audience from their seats when are hero steps up to the plate with his hickory slung over his shoulder. But when it comes to the magic of baseball, the stuff of legends which built the sport it goes a bit wrong, well not so much wrong but goes beyond the magic and into the realms of fantasy like theatrics making "The Natural" at times a bit too unbelievable. None of which actually makes any difference to the actual storyline, which is quite brilliant combining the under dog, too old to play storyline with a mystery element to deliver what is a very entertaining movie.

Richard Farnsworth and Wilford Brimley in The Natural (1984)

The way "The Natural" starts with a young Roy Hobbs playing baseball with his dad before making his special "Wonderboy" bat from an old tree struck by lightening sort of sets the mood for the fantasy elements which keep on cropping up throughout the movie. It's for me a bit over done, a bit too fantasy like and a little bit cheesy with heavily choreographed slow motion scenes stopping just short of being laughable which is a good thing.

Thankfully in between all these fantasy elements and scenes which include slugging balls out of the stadium, into flood lights and so on there is a good storyline, one which has a nice sense of mystery, a touch of romance, an element of humour and of course being a sports movie that under dog aspect. The fact that whilst "The Natural" has that sort of traditional storyline of a player too old to be playing in the majors, the fact it's wrapped up in a mystery makes it a lot more interesting. After the opening scenes which culminate with Hobbs young career being cut dramatically short you are left wondering what happened, especially when we pick things up 16 years later and Hobbs finally making it to the majors with the New York Knights. Of course we learn what happens but the whole mystery surrounding Hobbs who seems to arrive out of nowhere keeps you engrossed because you want to know, although the answer isn't as spectacular as I hoped for.

Thrown into the mix there are other story elements such as the dodgy owner and gambler who are trying to gain control of the New York Knights through under hand tactics delivering an entertaining match fixing sub plot which also brings with it a double romantic element. Strangely the romantic element doesn't feel out of place with Hobbs falling for the scheming Memo Paris, a character obviously based around a Marilyn Monroe like figure and also Hobbs's childhood sweetheart Iris Gaines. The romantic trysts add an embellishment to "The Natural" rather than just feeling like padding and also add to the fantasy mysticism especially when Iris turns up at a ball game just as Roy hits a batting slump and in that moment turns it around.

As for the performances well I wouldn't have chosen Robert Redford to appear in a baseball movie, but then I would have been proven wrong because he does a pretty decent job. He makes the mystery side of "The Natural" work delivering that tight lipped nature of someone trying to keep their past a secret, whilst also being handsome enough to carry off all the romantic elements in the story. In fact Redford looks so good for his age that it's hard to believe that he is just a couple of years younger than his co-star Wilford Brimley. But it is actually when he takes to the plate to slug a few balls or to the mound to pitch that Redford excels looking unbelievably natural as a baseball player with a god given talent.

Alongside Robert Redford there are many recognizable stars such as Glenn Close who gives a sweet and restrained performance as Iris Gaines and also Kim Bassinger who is both sultry and scheming as Memo Paris. But in a strange way it's the minor characters which make "The Natural" work so well with Robert Duvall delivering a fine performance as journalist Max Mercy, Wilford Brimley is equally as good as Pop Fisher the coach of the Knights and Robert Prosky delivers that evil owner in the same way that Lionel Barrymore delivered evil as Henry F. Potter in "It's a Wonderful life".

What this all boils down to is that "The Natural" is an entertaining movie and is much more than just a baseball movie about an old player getting his shot at the big time when he should be nearing the end of his career. It combines mystery, romance and even a little humour into the proceedings to make it far more interesting but then spoils things slightly by trying to hard to deliver the magic of the game with scenes which border on the fantasy like rather than being realistically magical.

Tags: Baseball Movies

Please support The Movie Scene by telling your friends and sharing this page:

Twitter Facebook Google LinkedIn Tumblr

Movie Recommendations

Eight Men Out

Eight Men Out (1988)

The Chicago White Sox team of 1919 may be a sure bet to win the World Series but the players are angry at their low pay thanks to th ...

The Rookie

The Rookie (2002)

Having been forced to give up on his dream of becoming a major league baseball star due to injury, Jimmy Morris (Dennis Quaid - Any ...

Field of Dreams

Field of Dreams (1989)

Having got married, started a family and settled down as a farmer in Iowa, Ray Kinsella (Kevin Costner - Bull Durham) is startled wh ...

Bull Durham

Bull Durham (1988)

Having spent serious money on untested pitcher Ebby Calvin 'Nuke' LaLoosh (Tim Robbins - Top Gun) and in the midst of a slump The Du ...

For Love of the Game

For Love of the Game (1999)

Billy Chapel (Kevin Costner - Silverado) is a baseball legend who having played for the same team all his life is forced to choose b ...

A Winner Never Quits

A Winner Never Quits (1986)

At a young age Pete Gray (Steve Rees / Keith Carradine) lost his right arm in a truck accident but it didn't stop him from trying to ...

A League of Their Own

A League of Their Own (1992)

The year is 1943 and with the war going on US professional baseball is suffering as its great players sign up. So Walter Harvey (Gar ...

The Babe

The Babe (1992)

"The Babe" covers the legends whole life from his childhood where he was abandoned at a reform school and labelled uncontrollable by ...

Hard Ball

Hard Ball (2001)

Conor O'Neill (Keanu Reeves) could have had a good career but he made a bet, then another and another and before long he was drownin ...

Hoosiers

Hoosiers (1986)

Based upon a true story "Hoosiers" stars Gene Hackman (Superman II) as Normal Dale a coach with a more than chequered past who finds ...

The Flying Scotsman

The Flying Scotsman (2006)

The year is 1993 and Graeme Obree (Jonny Lee Miller - Love, Honour and Obey) is an amateur cyclist who becomes unemployed when his c ...

Glory Road

Glory Road (2006)

After being invited to coach at Texas Western College Don Haskins (Josh Lucas - An Unfinished Life) finds it difficult to recruit an ...

Miracle

Miracle (2004)

After years of failure against the unstoppable Soviet Ice Hockey team, the USA employ University of Minnesota head coach Herb Brooks ...

Pride

Pride (2007)

As the only black swimmer on the swim team Jim Ellis (Terrence Howard - Get Rich or Die Tryin') met with a lot of racism, it lead to ...

The Greatest Game Ever Played

The Greatest Game Ever Played (2005)

Growing up opposite the Brookline Country Club, young Francis Ouimet (Shia LaBeouf - I, Robot) was attracted to playing golf, workin ...

Follow The Movie Scene

Follow The Movie Scene on Twitter Like The Movie Scene on facebook Join The Movie Scene on Gplus Subscribe to The Movie Scene's RSS