Colin Firth in Leather Trousers ... is that really what a girl wants?
No hugging, dear. I'm British. We only show affection to dogs and horses - Jocelyn Dashwood
Despite being an adaptation of William Douglas-Home's play "The Reluctant Debutante", "What a Girl Wants" fits solidly into the genre of fun, charming, obvious, fairytale not too dissimilar to the likes of "The Princes Diaries" and "The Prince and Me" when it comes to being every young girl's fantasy. It's so similar that there are aspects to "What a Girl Wants" that feel like generic must haves, required scenes to be included so it can be classed as another young girl's fairytale fantasy movie. But it also has a surprisingly good cast including Colin Firth and Sylvia Syms which make all the cutesy, gooey eyed fluff almost enjoyable, well for someone who really shouldn't be finding anything entertaining from a movie made for young girls.
Having grown up in New York with just her mother Libby (Kelly Preston - For Love of the Game), Daphne (Amanda Bynes - Big Fat Liar) has always wanted to meet her father, Henry Dashwood (Colin Firth - Hope springs) a British Lord, especially when ever she sees daughter's sharing a dance with their father's at the weddings she often waitresses at. So having turned 17 Daphne travels to Britain to meet her father who never knew she even existed, but with an election campaign in process and hiw own wedding on the cards it may not be so easy to fit into her father's well to do life.
So frankly the storyline to "What a Girl Wants" is as simple as they come, the young girl heading off to find her father who never knew she existed and so straight away delivering a possible happy ever after ending. Add to this that the father is a British Lord and perspective MP who is about to be married to a scheming social climber and who has an even more conniving social climbing daughter, which means not only do we get the fish out of water American in an overly British family but also skulduggery as certain people try to cause her to fail. I could go on and on including the romantic element of the handsome and charming young man, the quirky grandmother and much more because frankly the whole of "What a Girl Wants" feels familiar. Not that it is a criticism because the whole thing works together to provide an entertaining story for some comedy, romance and music.
What helps all these obvious story elements work is that "What a Girl Wants" is all good fun, maybe a little predictable in places but it brings a smile to your face. The humour is at a level that young children will find it amusing and coupled with all the cutesy fairytale stuff it works well. But as an adult there are elements which are just cringe worthy including an adhoc dance routine at a coming out ball as well as Colin Firth squeezing into some tight leather trousers to strut his funky stuff. These things probably work to make younger audiences laugh and enjoy "What a Girl Wants" but they are a little, well there's no other word for it cringe worthy.
But the thing which stands out is that the casting is for the most very good and in particular the obviously cute Amanda Bynes as Daphne Reynolds. Whilst when I first watched "What a Girl Wants" I had no idea who Amanda Bynes was she is perfect as the main character. She comes across as fun loving, cute but with a touch of that mischievous feistiness that you want but she is equally good when she tries to tone it down to become a lady. It's the enthusiasm of her performance which hides any weaknesses and makes many an obvious scene a little bit entertaining.
Alongside Bynes you have Colin Firth playing her father and basically playing the bumbling awfully nice English man that we've seen him do so many times before and to be frank he does so well. But in a movie aimed at young girls his bumbling and awkwardness works well to make him funny and along with the willingness to make a fool of himself with the dancing in leather trousers scene actually made you laugh as well as cringe.
Aside from Bynes and Firth there are various recognizable faces such as Kelly Preston playing Daphne's free willed mother, Jonathan Pryce as the slightly over the top scheming Alistair Payne and the always wonderful Sylvia Syms as Princess Charlotte. Although there are a couple of cringe worthy performances most notably from Oliver James as Ian the romantic interest as it is a weak character which floats in and out which doesn't help matters.
What this all boils down to is that "What a Girl Wants" is every inch a fluffy fairytale movie aimed at a young audience full of girls. But it is pleasant and manages to turn several obvious elements and comedy into a fun entertaining but not overly memorable movie. It's the sort of movie that if your young daughter wanted to watch you wouldn't find it completely devoid of fun.
Latest Movie Reviews
Born Innocent (1974)
Those who frequent The Movie Scene will know I am a fan of TV movies and have watched them from 70s TV movies right through to the 21st century ones. The difference between the TV movies of the 70s and those ...
Cross of Iron (1977)
I am a very sceptical movie reviewer, when ever I see that a movie is much loved I am always wary of the reasons why especially when a movie is made by a director who over the years have collected many fanboy...
Captain Apache (1971)
Have you ever heard Lee Van Cleef sing, just watch the opening credits to "Captain Apache" and you will hear him singing the title music, although in truth coolly reading the lyrics seem a more apt descriptio...
Warlords of Atlantis (1978)
I've always enjoyed those adventure movies which take us on journeys into the unknown, be it down a volcano to the center of the Earth or to an encounter with a legendary Sea captain aboard his submarine. But...
She's the Man (2006)
What is it with teen movies and The Bard, is it some sort of grand plan to make the works of Shakespeare more interesting to younger ...
I've never watched the original version of "Hairspray" reason being that whilst meant to be his most accessible movie I find the cre ...
Living Proof (2008)
People tend to have negative opinions of TV movies thinking they are the crude often vacuous relatives of big screen movies but once ...
Easy A (2010)
During the 80s John Hughes was the man for making teen movies, he was able to take teenage troubles and have fun with them whilst al ...
Sydney White (2007)
2007 was a good year for geeks, not only did "The Big Bang Theory" hit the small screen but "Sydney White" hit the big screen. Now " ...