When Sutton (Italia Ricci) arrives at her mother's luxurious home there is no reply so she lets herself in only to discover her sister April (Magda Apanowicz
) crouched over her mother's body with a blooded kitchen knife in her hand. Traumatized, April can't remember a single thing which happened and she is placed into a psychiatric facility much to the annoyance of Detective Whitaker (Shauna Johannesen) who is convinced April murdered her own mother. A year later and April still has no memories from the fateful night but is released into Sutton's custody to face trial with Sutton representing her. But April's staying with Sutton annoys Sutton's husband Glenn (Zak Santiago) who works with the girl's stepfather Orly (Kevin McNulty) causing friction at home. But the situation worsens as Sutton tries to help April remember what happened that night.
I have decided that I need another category for movies, those which are too obvious that they can't be that obvious and "Fatal Memories" would be right at the top of that category. Why? Well right from the word go the character of Orly is hinted at that he is the murderer and it doesn't do a good job of hiding this from him creeping around to giving April a car with faulty brakes. But it is so intentional that as you watch "Fatal Memories" you find yourself thinking that surely it can't be that obvious, it must be someone else; maybe the put out Glenn, maybe it was April or how about the detective who seems to have an unexplained dislike of Sutton. I won't say as to how "Fatal Memories" ends, or what surprises there may be along the way but I will say it doesn't devote any time at all when it comes to delivering the killer's motive.
What that means is that "Fatal Memories" consists of following Sutton around who actually doesn't seem to do much when it comes to finding evidence. This is interspersed with Glenn acting cheesed off along with Orly seeming to appear out of nowhere all the time as if he is stalking people. The knock on effect of this is the camera spends an inordinate amount of time focused on Italia Ricci who in fairness does a typical TV movie job of playing Sutton but the camera constantly seems to zoom in on her looks which are appealing but what you want is more than Ricci looking hot in a tight dress.
What this all boils down to is that "Fatal Memories" it typical of the modern made for TV movie genre with a focus on looks over the story telling or atmosphere. But this is one movie which makes you think that it really can't be as obvious as it is making things out to be which is what keeps you watching more than for the actual story.